Hi! This is why I always tell people to speak to a Realtor or an Attorney before you sign anything. A plain Convenient if one thing (no fences more than 4 feet, (you can file for a variance), but a CC&R is just what it is. And once you signed this, you acknowledged a full understanding and agreement to it. Whether the Builder/LLC formed with/an agreement under the guidance of the Planing Board, Building, Zoning or what every town committee was involved, this is a valid, legal agreement.
While Real Estate Law varies in some State, I called my classmates Husband in Vero Beach, originally from San Fran. He is head of the Planning and City Development Board. He said that while some people think this is not fair, then go buy somewhere else. If they signed a CC & R with the full intent not to abide by this, then this is fraud. You then could have two problems. No one should ever sign any document like this without a Realtor or Attorney review this and advise them. Modifications may have been negotiated. The other thing is enforcement. I asked him how could this be enforced? He said the judge will do that after you get a summons to appear in court.
He also told me as a former member of the Board of the National Real Estate Asoc., that if you had had a attorney represent you at the closing, you may have been able to amend this with some amicable conditions. However, it is what it is, and you can live in the house or re-sell it. Violation of the CC&R could be extremely costly even with just attorney fees and court costs. However, before you get crazy with websites promising you a legal out. Take time to find a LOCAL real Estate attorney for that area that may know the builder/planning board members etc. Call him. Bring all your paperwork and sit down with him. Listen to what he tells you as he will give you the BEST advise and possible solutions. You are paying him for his 1/2 -1 hour, so listen to him, perhaps he can work some magic. It is worth the monies if you can find a reasonable compromise that benefits all and offends no one. If you have any other questions, please ask. Good luck!!
REMEMBER to click the ACCEPT button if this helped you.